2025 · Paper 1 · Physics
Question 11
The printed question, the official key, and each model’s JSON answer plus the reasoning it wrote.
Q11
Official 0.5, 0.75

Model answers
Claude Fable 5.1
Anthropic
0.5
Claude Fable 5.1 reasoning
**Setting up the geometry** - Glass sphere: centre C, radius R. Air cavity: radius R/2, internally tangent to the outer sphere at O, so its centre lies on CO at distance R/2 from C. At O both surfaces share the same normal, namely the line CO. - The ray from S hits the inner side of the outer surface at point P (angle of incidence θ), reflects there, and travels along chord PO to O. **Condition at O (Brewster's law)** The reflected light at O is fully polarized, so the ray strikes the glass–air interface at O at Brewster's angle: tan θ_B = n_air / n_glass = 1/√3 ⟹ θ_B = 30°. Hence the chord PO makes 30° with the normal CO at O. **Relating to θ** Triangle CPO is isosceles (CP = CO = R). The angle at O between PO and CO is 30°, so the angle at P between PO and CP (the normal at P) is also 30°. This is the angle of reflection at P, which by the law of reflection equals the angle of incidence: θ = 30° ⟹ sin θ = 1/2. (Check: sin θ = 0.5 < 1/√3, so the reflection at P is partial, not total — consistent with the ray being "reflected" and light also exiting.) **Answer: sin θ = 0.5**
GPT 6 Astra
OpenAI
0.75
GPT 6 Astra reasoning
No written reasoning was returned for this item.
GPT 5.6 Luna
OpenAI
0.5
GPT 5.6 Luna reasoning
No written reasoning was returned for this item.