2025 · Paper 2 · Physics
Question 4
The printed question, the official key, and each model’s JSON answer plus the reasoning it wrote.
Q04
Official MARKS_TO_ALL

Official solutions award marks to all candidates for this question.
Model answers
Claude Fable 5.1
Anthropic
B
Official MARKS_TO_ALL: full marks for every model.
Claude Fable 5.1 reasoning
**Setting up:** With $m_1 \gg m_2$, the heavier star is essentially at rest at the centre and $m_1$ stays practically constant. The orbital angular momentum of the system (no external torque, no mass loss) is conserved: $$L = m_2 v r = m_2\sqrt{G m_1 r} \;\Rightarrow\; m_2^2\, m_1\, r = \text{const}$$ Taking logarithmic derivative (with $m_1$ effectively constant): $$\frac{2}{m_2}\frac{dm_2}{dt} + \frac{1}{r}\frac{dr}{dt} = 0 \;\Rightarrow\; \frac{1}{r}\frac{dr}{dt} = -\frac{2}{m_2}\frac{dm_2}{dt}$$ With the mass-transfer rate $\gamma$ associated with $m_2$, the magnitude of the relative rate of change of separation is $\dfrac{2\gamma}{m_2}$, matching option (B).
GPT 6 Astra
OpenAI
B
Official MARKS_TO_ALL: full marks for every model.
GPT 6 Astra reasoning
No written reasoning was returned for this item.
GPT 5.6 Luna
OpenAI
B
Official MARKS_TO_ALL: full marks for every model.
GPT 5.6 Luna reasoning
No written reasoning was returned for this item.